Marshall County Grand Jury Issues August Indictments

The following suspects were indicted Tuesday, August 13th by a Marshall County Grand Jury. An indictment is not a finding of guilt or innocence, but rather indicates a jury has found that enough evidence exists to present a case in court. All suspects are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.

Ray D. Dufay, 58, of 557 JH O’Bryan Ave., Grand Rivers: Theft by deception over $500 but less than $10,000 (Complicity); Devising or engaging in a scheme to defraud the Kentucky Medical Assistance Program of $300 or more (Complicity)

Melissa Ann Dufay, 59, of 557 JH O’Bryan Ave., Grand Rivers: Devising or engaging in a scheme to defraud the Kentucky Medical Assistance Program of $300 or more (Complicity)

Nicole J. Reichard, 32, of 115 W 1st St., Benton: First degree, first offense, trafficking in a controlled substance (greater than or equal to 2 grams of methamphetamine); Tampering with physical evidence; Theft of a motor vehicle registration plate/renewal decal; Third degree, first offense, trafficking in a controlled substance (less than 20 dosage units drug unspecified); Operating on a suspended/revoked operators license; First offense, failure of owner to maintain required insurance/security; Improper display of registration plate; No/Expired Kentucky registration receipt; No/Expired registration plates; Failure to produce insurance card; Second degree, persistent felony offender

Tanner D. Stevenson, 24, of 32 S Alabama St, Calvert City: Second Degree Rape – No Force (2 Counts)

Justin A. Seaford, 29, of 474 Mayfield HWY, Benton: Tampering with physical evidence; Second degree, first offense, trafficking in a controlled substance (less than 20 dosage units drug unspecified); Second degree, hindering prosecution or apprehension

John Gay, 53, of 1331 Dogtown Rd., Benton: Second degree, first offense, trafficking in a controlled substance (less than 20 dosage units drug unspecified)-enhanced; Illegal possession of a legend drug; First offense, controlled substance prescription not in original container

Blake A. Williams, 25, of 140 Halzelnut Ln., Dexter: First degree, first offense, possession of a controlled substance (methamphetamine)-enhanced; Possession of drug paraphernalia

Terry Rudd, 41, of 853 Retirement Circle, Calvert City: First degree sexual abuse, victim under 12 years of age; Second degree, persistent felony offender

Matthew L. McKinney, 33, of 3563 US HWY 68 E, Benton: First degree, first offense, possession of a controlled substance (methamphetamine); Possession of drug paraphernalia

Travis W. Isaacs, 31, of 212 W 9th St., Benton: First degree, fleeing or evading police (motor vehicle); Resisting arrest; Third offense, operating a motor vehicle under the influence of alcohol, drugs, etc. with .08 aggravated circumstance; Reckless driving; Speeding 20 MPH over the limit; Disregarding a traffic control device, traffic light; Disregarding a stop sign

Rachel A. Fryer, 34, of 1622 Starks Cemetery Rd., Hardin: Theft by unlawful taking or disposition controlled substance under $10,000; Third degree, forgery

Patricia Matheny, 60, of 360 Oak Valley Rd., Benton: Theft of property lost or mislaid greater than $500